- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
Industrial Waste Phase Separation Troubleshooting: How to Break Stable Emulsions and Restore Settling
This article provides a step-by-step, expert checklist to diagnose and fix lack of phase separation in industrial waste streams so facilities can recover oil, thicken sludge, and meet discharge limits.
1. Define the Separation Failure
Classify the problem before changing equipment or chemistry.
- Oil–water emulsion: Milky appearance, no clear interface, fine droplet size below 10 µm.
- Solids–liquid poor settling: Cloudy supernatant, rising sludge, slow or stalled sedimentation.
- Foam-dominated surface: Stable foam layer preventing coalescence and skimming.
- Salts or surfactants present: High conductivity, low surface tension, high COD from detergents.
2. Quick Field Diagnostics
| Field test | Target | Typical acceptance | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|---|
| pH | Charge neutralization window | 5.5–7.0 for alum/PACl, 6.0–8.0 for most organics. | Out-of-range pH sustains zeta potential and prevents floc. |
| Temperature | Viscosity and interfacial tension | >20°C for heavy oils if safe. | Cold streams raise viscosity and slow coalescence and settling. |
| Conductivity | Ionic strength | Application specific. | Very low ionic strength impedes charge screening; very high may salt-in surfactants. |
| Jar test (six-beaker) | Coagulant and polymer window | Clear supernatant in 5–10 min. | Determines dose, sequence, and mixing energy. |
| Bottle test with demulsifier | Oil–water break | Distinct interface <10 min. | Confirms need for demulsifier and dosage range. |
| Microscopy | Droplet and floc size | Coalesced droplets >50 µm for gravity separators. | Fine droplets indicate surfactant stabilization or high shear. |
3. Root Causes and High-Leverage Fixes
| Root cause | Symptoms | Verification | Primary fix | Secondary fix |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Surfactant-stabilized emulsion | Milky phase, no interface. | Low surface tension; stable foam. | Demulsifier or acid crack to pH 4–5, then neutralize. | Salt addition to increase ionic strength; heat if safe. |
| pH outside coagulant window | Light floc, poor settle. | Field pH vs jar-test optimum. | Adjust pH into optimum before coagulant. | Switch to coagulant tolerant of current pH. |
| Under/overdosed coagulant | Cloudy effluent, pin floc. | Jar test curve vs current dose. | Titrate to minimum effective dose. | Stage addition with rapid/slow mix control. |
| Polymer shear or wrong charge density | Broken floc, slimy sludge. | Viscosity loss across pump; zeta potential trend. | Move polymer injection downstream of high-shear devices. | Change to higher Mw, lower shear sensitivity, matched charge. |
| Excess mixing energy | Micro-droplets, foam. | High G-values in in-line mixers. | Reduce G or residence time; add quiescent zone. | Swap to plate coalescer with low shear entry. |
| Cold, viscous feed | Slow separation. | T below 20°C, high viscosity. | Heat exchangers or maintain insulated lines. | Longer residence time; larger separator. |
| Hydraulic short-circuiting | Bypass of coalescer/clarifier. | Tracer test, CFD, dead zones. | Install baffles, flow distributors, lamella packs. | Balance flows among parallel trains. |
| High TSS or FOG shock load | Carryover and scum. | Load profile vs design. | Equalization tank; surge control. | DAF or CPI retrofit upstream. |
4. Chemistry: Proven Sequences That Work
Sequence matters more than individual chemicals. Use jar tests to set the window.
- Oil–water emulsion: Acidify to pH 4–5 to protonate surfactants. Add demulsifier at moderate mix for 30–60 s. Adjust to pH 6–7.5. Dose inorganic coagulant. Follow with anionic flocculant under gentle mix. Allow 5–10 min quiescent settling or route to DAF.
- High colloidal solids: pH setpoint from jar test. Alum or PACl for charge neutralization. Add cationic polymer as coagulant aid. Finish with high Mw anionic flocculant for bridging.
- Proteinaceous or food waste: Enzymatic pre-break or oxidant trim if permitted. Then standard coagulation–flocculation.
| Agent | Typical dose range | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Alum (Al₂(SO₄)₃) | 50–300 mg/L as product. | Best at pH 5.5–7.0. Generates sludge. |
| PACl or ACH | 30–200 mg/L. | Wider pH window, faster kinetics. |
| Ferric chloride/sulfate | 20–150 mg/L Fe³⁺. | Handles oily streams, good sweeping floc. |
| Cationic polyDADMAC/EPI-DMA | 5–50 mg/L. | Charge neutralization; avoid overdosing. |
| Anionic flocculant (PAM) | 0.5–5 mg/L. | High Mw. Add last with gentle mixing. |
| Demulsifier (nonionic/cationic) | 10–200 ppm. | Select via bottle test; match oil type. |
| pH adjusters (H₂SO₄, NaOH) | As required. | Set pH before coagulant; trim after. |
5. Physics: Target Droplet and Particle Size
Gravity separators and clarifiers require minimum droplet or particle sizes.
- Stokes’ law settling velocity (laminar):
v = ( (ρ_p − ρ_f) * g * d^2 ) / (18 * μ) # v: settling velocity (m/s) # ρ_p: particle density, ρ_f: fluid density, μ: viscosity, d: diameter Design clarifier residence time so target particles achieve v·t ≥ depth.
- Oil droplet rise velocity (creaming): Use Stokes’ law with ρ_p as oil and reverse sign. For CPI/plate coalescers, design for ≥50–100 µm droplets at entry. Use low-shear inlet to protect droplet size distribution.
6. Equipment Changes With Highest Return
- Lamella plates in clarifier: Increase projected area. Reduce footprint and short-circuiting.
- Corrugated plate interceptor (CPI) or parallel plate coalescer: Promotes droplet coalescence and separation at lower velocities.
- Dissolved air flotation (DAF): Capture fine oil and light solids. Maintain recycle 10–30% and saturator 4–6 bar.
- Equalization tank: Damp load swings and stabilize chemistry.
- Low-shear pumps and piping: Positive displacement or low NPSH centrifugal. Avoid needle valves and sharp elbows before separators.
7. Operating Windows That Prevent Re-Emulsification
| Parameter | Recommended setpoint | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Rapid mix G·t | 20,000–60,000 s⁻¹·s. | Complete coagulant dispersion without over-shearing floc. |
| Flocculation G | 20–60 s⁻¹ for 10–20 min. | Grow robust floc size and strength. |
| DAF recycle | 10–30% of influent. | Ensures bubble density for capture. |
| Polymer solution aging | 30–60 min post-make-down. | Fully uncoil polymer chains for performance. |
| Coalescer flux | ≤5–10 m³/m²·h for heavy oils. | Protects residence time and droplet contact. |
| Temperature | >20°C if compatible. | Lowers viscosity and accelerates separation. |
Caution: Never add incompatible chemicals together or inject undiluted polymer into high-shear pump suctions. Verify permits before using oxidants, enzymes, or heat. Control pH shifts to avoid toxic gas release when acids contact sulfide-bearing waste.
8. Standard Operating Procedures
Use these minimal SOPs to regain separation fast.
# Six-Beaker Jar Test SOP 1. Collect representative composite sample. Keep at process temperature. 2. Adjust pH in each beaker to a different value within 4.0–8.0. 3. Rapid mix: 300 rpm for 60 s. Dose coagulant series (e.g., 30–300 mg/L). 4. Reduce to 40 rpm for 10 min. Dose flocculant at 0.5–5 mg/L during first minute. 5. Stop mixing. Settle for 10 min. Record supernatant turbidity, color, and interface. 6. Pick the lowest-dose, clear result. Confirm with a duplicate run including demulsifier if oil is present. # DAF Startup SOP (after chemistry is set) 1. Pressurize saturator to 4–6 bar. Establish recycle at 10–30% of influent. 2. Target whitewater with fine, uniform bubbles. Adjust air/water ratio accordingly. 3. Inject polymer immediately upstream of flocculator at low shear. 4. Start influent at 60–80% design flux. Skim continuously. Track blanket height. 5. Optimize skimmer speed and recycle to minimize carryover and maximize clarity. 9. Monitoring and Control
- Track turbidity, oil and grease, TSS, pH, temperature, and polymer flow in a control chart.
- Correlate effluent clarity to jar test dose and pH to maintain within control limits.
- Audit shear sources weekly: valves, pumps, throttled bypasses, and inline static mixers.
10. Acceptance Criteria and Readiness to Return to Spec
- Oil–water: distinct interface within 10 minutes and effluent FOG within permit or internal target.
- Solids–liquid: supernatant turbidity meets internal KPI after 10–20 minutes settle in jar test.
- Sludge: solids concentration and dewaterability (capillary suction time) return to baseline.
FAQ
Is pH or coagulant type more important for breaking emulsions?
pH is the first lever because it sets charge state and interfacial chemistry. Coagulant selection is second. Set pH first, then titrate coagulant and polymer by jar test.
When should I switch from gravity separation to DAF?
Switch when effective droplet sizes are below 50–100 µm, when surfactant load is high, or when footprint limits residence time. DAF provides attachment and buoyancy that gravity lacks.
Can heating alone fix lack of separation?
Heating reduces viscosity and can weaken surfactant films, but chemistry and low shear are often still required. Verify safety, energy cost, and permit constraints before heating.
How do I prevent re-emulsification after the separator?
Eliminate high-shear elements downstream, keep flow laminar into skimmers, and avoid exporting partially treated streams back to upstream high-shear zones.
What if polymer keeps “snotting” or forming gels?
Likely overdilution without aging or injection into a high-shear region. Make down at manufacturer-recommended concentration, age for 30–60 minutes, and inject downstream of pumps.