- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
This article explains how to design, build, and troubleshoot robust nonlinear optimization models in Excel using Solver, so that analysts and modelers can move beyond simple linear models and apply advanced nonlinear techniques with confidence.
1. Understanding nonlinear optimization in Excel
Nonlinear optimization in Excel refers to maximizing or minimizing an objective function that contains nonlinear relationships among the decision variables, subject to linear or nonlinear constraints, using the Solver add-in.
While linear programming models in Excel rely on straight-line relationships and can be handled by the Simplex LP engine, many real-world problems involve curvature, ratios, products, or exponentials that require nonlinear optimization methods.
1.1 Linear vs nonlinear models in spreadsheets
A model is linear when all formulas used in the objective and constraints are linear combinations of the decision variables, without products of variables, powers, or nonlinear functions such as SQRT, EXP, or LOG.
A model is nonlinear when at least one formula in the objective or constraints involves a nonlinear function of the decision variables, such as squared terms, products of variables, or non-polynomial functions like SIN, COS, or IF with changing regions.
Excel formulas that often introduce nonlinearity into optimization models include functions such as POWER, SQRT, EXP, LN, LOG, SIN, COS, TAN, and multiplications between decision-variable cells.
1.2 Typical business applications of nonlinear optimization in Excel
Nonlinear optimization models in Excel are frequently used in engineering design, finance, marketing, and operations, where curvature or diminishing returns must be captured realistically.
Typical examples include portfolio optimization with nonlinear risk measures, calibration of pricing or demand curves, fitting nonlinear regression models, blending problems with nonlinear yield relationships, and scheduling problems with penalty functions that grow faster than linearly.
In many organizations, these models start as ordinary spreadsheets, and the optimization step is added later using Solver rather than switching to dedicated optimization software immediately.
2. Excel Solver engines for nonlinear models
Excel Solver provides three main solving engines: Simplex LP, GRG Nonlinear, and Evolutionary, and the appropriate choice depends on whether the model is linear, smooth nonlinear, or non-smooth nonlinear.
2.1 GRG Nonlinear method
The GRG Nonlinear engine (Generalized Reduced Gradient) is designed for smooth nonlinear optimization problems where the objective function and constraints are continuously differentiable with respect to the decision variables.
GRG uses gradient information to move toward a local optimum that satisfies the Karush–Kuhn–Tucker (KKT) conditions, assuming appropriate regularity conditions are met.
Because GRG is a local search method, its final solution depends on the starting values of the decision variables, and different starting points may lead to different local optima.
GRG Nonlinear is efficient for well-scaled models with smooth curvature, such as engineering design problems with continuous design variables and differentiable constraints.
2.2 Evolutionary Solver for non-smooth models
The Evolutionary Solver in Excel is a population-based algorithm inspired by evolutionary computation, designed to handle non-smooth, discontinuous, or highly non-convex models.
Unlike GRG, the Evolutionary algorithm does not rely on derivatives and can handle models with IF, MAX, MIN, and other non-smooth functions that introduce kinks or discontinuities into the objective or constraints.
Because it samples and evolves a population of candidate solutions, the Evolutionary Solver is more likely to approximate a global optimum in complex landscapes but is substantially slower and more resource intensive than GRG for the same model.
2.3 Choosing between GRG and Evolutionary in practice
For smooth nonlinear models with differentiable formulas, GRG Nonlinear is usually the first choice due to its speed and efficiency.
For models containing non-smooth elements such as IF-based logic, binary variables approximated by constraints, or penalty functions built with MAX and MIN, the Evolutionary Solver is often more reliable.
For non-convex smooth models where local optima are a concern, it is common to use GRG with multiple starting points and then cross-check the best solution with an Evolutionary run using tight variable bounds.
| Engine | Best for | Strengths | Limitations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Simplex LP | Strictly linear models | Very fast and robust for large linear problems | Cannot handle nonlinear formulas |
| GRG Nonlinear | Smooth nonlinear models | Efficient, supports derivatives, good for engineering and calibration models | Local optima only, sensitive to starting values |
| Evolutionary | Non-smooth or highly non-convex models | More likely to approximate global optima, handles IF, MAX, MIN | Much slower, results vary between runs, requires good bounds |
Note : In nonlinear optimization models, using GRG Nonlinear on a non-smooth model often leads to poor convergence or misleading solutions, so always verify that your formulas are differentiable before selecting GRG.
3. Structuring a nonlinear optimization model in Excel
A nonlinear optimization model in Excel consists of decision variable cells, an objective cell, and constraint formulas that depend on those variables, arranged in a transparent, auditable layout.
The key to a maintainable nonlinear model is separating inputs, decision variables, and outputs, and minimizing implicit dependencies or hidden calculations scattered across the workbook.
3.1 Defining decision variables
Decision variables are cells that Solver will change to optimize the objective, such as product mix quantities, investment weights, or parameter estimates in a calibration model.
Decision variables should be placed in a compact, contiguous range and clearly labeled with descriptive headers, and should not be mixed with fixed input data.
It is good practice to impose explicit lower and upper bounds on decision variables, both to reflect realistic physical or business constraints and to help the Solver search efficiently.
3.2 Building a nonlinear objective function
The objective cell contains a formula that aggregates decision variables into a scalar measure to be maximized or minimized, such as profit, cost, error, or risk.
For nonlinear optimization, the objective often contains quadratic, exponential, or logarithmic relationships, for example a squared-error term in calibration or a quadratic risk measure in portfolio optimization.
The following example shows a nonlinear least-squares objective that minimizes the sum of squared residuals between observed and predicted values.
' Suppose: ' B2:B101 contains observed values y ' C2:C101 contains predicted values ŷ depending on decision variable parameters ' The objective cell D2 computes the sum of squared residuals =SUMXMY2(B2:B101, C2:C101) This objective is nonlinear in the parameters if the predicted values depend nonlinearly on the decision variables, such as in exponential or logistic models.
3.3 Modeling nonlinear constraints
Constraints restrict the feasible region of the optimization model and can themselves be nonlinear in the decision variables.
Nonlinear constraints are common in engineering design (e.g., stress constraints that depend quadratically on geometry), finance (e.g., risk constraints with covariance matrices), and ratio limits (e.g., performance metrics expressed as nonlinear functions of lower-level variables).
In Excel, each constraint is defined as a cell formula whose value is related to a limit using operators such as <=, >=, or = when setting up Solver.
' Example of a nonlinear risk constraint: ' w is a vector of portfolio weights in B2:B6 ' Covariance matrix is stored in C2:G6 ' Risk measure cell H2 computes portfolio variance =MMULT(TRANSPOSE(B2:B6), MMULT(C2:G6, B2:B6)) ' Then you can impose H2 <= MaxVariance in Solver. Whenever possible, keep constraint formulas numerically stable and well scaled, avoiding extreme magnitudes that can hinder Solver convergence.
3.4 Setting up Solver for a nonlinear model
Once the model structure is in place, you must configure Solver to use the right engine and options for nonlinear optimization.
A typical configuration workflow for a nonlinear model in Excel is as follows.
First, go to Data and launch Solver, then set the objective cell to the cell containing the nonlinear objective formula.
Second, choose Max, Min, or Value Of according to whether you are maximizing, minimizing, or targeting a specific value for the objective.
Third, specify the By Changing Variable Cells range to include all decision variable cells and only those cells.
Fourth, add all constraint cells and their relationships using the Add button, including variable bounds if they are not already embedded in formulas.
Fifth, open the Options dialog, select GRG Nonlinear or Evolutionary depending on model smoothness, and configure settings such as precision, convergence, and population size as appropriate.
| Option group | Key setting | Typical recommendation for nonlinear models |
|---|---|---|
| All Methods | Constraint Precision | Use default initially, tighten if constraints are slightly violated. |
| GRG Nonlinear | Convergence | Start with default, then reduce (e.g., from 1E-4 to 1E-6) for higher accuracy. |
| Evolutionary | Population Size and Mutation | Increase population for complex landscapes and allow moderate mutation for exploration. |
| All Methods | Max Time and Iterations | Increase limits for large nonlinear models to avoid premature termination. |
Note : For large nonlinear models, do not rely solely on default Solver settings; explicitly increasing Max Time and Iterations and tuning convergence tolerances can dramatically affect solution quality.
4. Worked example: nonlinear portfolio optimization in Excel
This section outlines a typical nonlinear portfolio optimization model implemented entirely in Excel, using GRG Nonlinear or Evolutionary Solver depending on the smoothness of the risk measure and constraints.
4.1 Model structure and data layout
Assume a portfolio of five assets with expected returns and a covariance matrix estimated from historical data.
| Cell | Description | Example |
|---|---|---|
| A2:A6 | Asset names | Asset1, Asset2, ..., Asset5 |
| B2:B6 | Decision variable weights w | Initial guess, e.g., 0.20 each |
| C2:C6 | Expected returns | Annualized means |
| D2:H6 | Covariance matrix | Symmetric matrix of variances and covariances |
| C8 | Expected portfolio return | =SUMPRODUCT(B2:B6, C2:C6) |
| C9 | Portfolio variance | =MMULT(TRANSPOSE(B2:B6), MMULT(D2:H6, B2:B6)) |
Decision variables are the weights in B2:B6, which must satisfy the budget and possibly additional constraints.
4.2 Objective and constraints
One common nonlinear objective is to minimize portfolio variance subject to a minimum expected return threshold.
' Objective cell C9 (variance) is to be minimized. ' Constraints might include: SUM(B2:B6) = 1 ' Full investment B2:B6 >= 0 ' Long-only portfolio C8 >= TargetReturn ' Minimum expected return The variance formula is quadratic in the weights, making the model intrinsically nonlinear and a good candidate for GRG Nonlinear or Evolutionary engines.
4.3 Configuring Solver for the portfolio model
In the Solver dialog, set the objective to the variance cell and choose Min to minimize risk while satisfying constraints.
Set the By Changing Variable Cells range to B2:B6 and add the sum-to-one and non-negativity constraints, as well as the minimum return constraint.
Choose GRG Nonlinear as the solving method for a smooth quadratic risk model, or choose Evolutionary if additional non-smooth features such as cardinality constraints or stepwise transaction costs are added.
Run Solver and examine whether solutions meet constraints and produce a realistic asset allocation consistent with business or regulatory constraints.
5. Advanced techniques for nonlinear optimization in Excel
Complex nonlinear optimization models in Excel often require careful numerical engineering and advanced Solver configuration to achieve stable, meaningful solutions.
5.1 Scaling and conditioning
Well-scaled models, where variable magnitudes and objective values are within a few orders of magnitude of one another, tend to converge more reliably under GRG Nonlinear and other gradient-based methods.
If some variables or constraints are much larger in magnitude than others, consider rescaling units, normalizing variables, or dividing large terms by constants to bring numbers into a tighter range.
It is also helpful to avoid extremely small or large powers that can lead to numerical underflow or overflow in Excel formulas.
5.2 Multiple starting points and robustness checks
Because nonlinear optimization in Excel is often subject to local optima, it is good practice to test multiple starting points for decision variables and compare resulting objective values.
One approach is to generate several sets of random or systematically varied initial values inside realistic bounds, run Solver for each configuration, and retain the best solution encountered.
Another approach is to use Evolutionary Solver for a broader exploration of the search space and then refine the best candidate solutions using GRG Nonlinear starting from those points.
5.3 Handling non-smooth formulas
Excel models often use IF, MAX, MIN, ABS, and similar functions to represent operational rules, penalties, or thresholds, which introduce non-smoothness in the objective or constraints.
If the non-smooth regions are critical to the model, consider using the Evolutionary Solver engine and ensure that variable bounds are tight and realistic to keep the search manageable.
If possible, approximate non-smooth elements with smooth surrogate functions, such as using differentiable penalty or logistic approximations, to enable GRG Nonlinear to exploit gradient information.
5.4 Integrating nonlinear optimization with sensitivity analysis
After solving a nonlinear optimization model, it is valuable to assess how sensitive the optimal solution is to changes in key parameters, such as cost coefficients, demand forecasts, or risk estimates.
In Excel, this can be performed by rerunning Solver under different scenarios, using Data Tables to propagate parameter variations, or using Scenario Manager combined with Solver runs.
Because nonlinear models can exhibit non-intuitive behavior, sensitivity analysis is important to identify fragile solutions and to communicate uncertainty to stakeholders.
6. Testing and validating nonlinear Excel models
Validation is essential for nonlinear optimization models, since errors in formulas or inappropriate Solver settings can produce solutions that look plausible but are structurally incorrect.
6.1 Sanity checks on model inputs and outputs
Before running Solver, verify that all input data ranges are complete, consistent, and correctly referenced in formulas, especially covariance matrices, regression data, or engineering property tables.
After solving, check whether constraints are satisfied within acceptable tolerances and whether decision variable values make sense in the real-world context.
Whenever possible, compare Solver results against simple hand-calculated or small-scale benchmark cases where the solution is known or easy to approximate.
6.2 Auditing formulas and dependency paths
Use Excel auditing tools such as Trace Precedents and Trace Dependents to confirm that objective and constraint cells only depend on intended data and decision variables.
Document assumptions, units, and formula logic clearly near the model area, so that the nonlinear structure is understandable to others reviewing the workbook.
Maintain version control for complex nonlinear models, especially when multiple modelers collaborate or when the workbook is used as a production tool.
6.3 When to move beyond Excel
For small to mid-sized nonlinear optimization problems, Excel Solver is often sufficient, especially when users already live in the spreadsheet environment.
For very large, stiff, or highly structured nonlinear models, it may be more appropriate to migrate to specialized optimization platforms or algebraic modeling languages, using Excel primarily for data preparation and reporting.
FAQ
When should I use GRG Nonlinear instead of the Evolutionary Solver in Excel.
Use GRG Nonlinear when the objective function and constraints are smooth and differentiable with respect to the decision variables, such as quadratic or exponential models without IF, MAX, or MIN functions, because GRG can exploit gradient information to converge quickly to a local optimum.
If the model includes non-smooth features or if GRG fails to converge reliably, consider switching to the Evolutionary Solver.
How do I reduce the risk of getting stuck in local optima in nonlinear Excel models.
To reduce the risk of local optima, run Solver from multiple starting points, use realistic but not overly tight bounds on decision variables, and experiment with the Evolutionary Solver for a broader search of the solution space.
Comparing objective values and solution patterns across runs helps identify whether the model consistently converges to the same high-quality solution.
What are the most common reasons Solver fails on nonlinear models in Excel.
Common causes include poor scaling of variables and constraints, missing or incorrect formula references, unrealistic starting values, and mis-specified bounds that make the feasible region empty or extremely narrow.
Adjusting scaling, checking formulas carefully, relaxing overly strict constraints, and increasing iteration and time limits often resolves convergence issues.
Can I include integer or binary decisions in nonlinear optimization models in Excel.
Yes, Excel Solver can handle integer and binary decision variables in nonlinear models, but the problem becomes more complex and may require the Evolutionary Solver to explore the discrete decision space effectively.
For large mixed-integer nonlinear problems, however, Solver may struggle, and specialized optimization software may be more suitable.
How do I document nonlinear optimization models so that others can maintain them.
Document the purpose of the model, define all decision variables, inputs, and outputs, annotate key formulas, and summarize Solver settings in a dedicated documentation sheet.
Using clear labels, consistent naming, and grouped ranges makes it easier for colleagues to understand, audit, and extend the nonlinear optimization model.